It’s tempting when reading these two pieces
- Community fridges pop up in Toronto neighbourhoods during COVID-19 pandemic– …
- Councillor blasts group building shelters after altercation at Dartmouth park
to say, “at least they’re trying”. Or to ask “what’s the alternative”. Or even to think “you don’t support these ideas because you are “heartless, bourgeois, selfish,” etc.
First off, let me say the impulse of these initiatives are good. And the alternatives — lack of food and shelter — are terrible. So in that way these are good ideas. Some food and some shelter is better than none.
But in comparison to any other initiative involving food and shelter these ideas are poor ones. These shelters are good because they are shelters and nothing else. And the idea of having a community fridge is a disaster waiting to happen.
I’m glad that these initiatives provoke the comfortable to make a better effort to help the poor and homeless. But I will never think these are good works for any reason other than the basic ones.
Not every act of kindness is good, and sometimes a small act of kindness allows a bigger problem to fester.