In reading Clive Thompson’s latest linkfest, I came across the above painting by Thomas Cole. It illustrates a section of his newsletter talking about how the collapse of empires can lead to benefits for those other than the 1%. I highly recommend not just that section, “3) 🌋 The upside of societal collapse”, but the entire newsletter.
I’d also recommend you check out all five paintings from this series:
- The Savage State, or The Commencement of Empire
- The Arcadian or Pastoral State
- The Consummation of Empire
- Destruction
- Desolation
Cole’s paintings imply an arc that goes from Commencement to Desolation, with Consumption being a peak. However based on the newsletter and the book it references to, “Goliath’s Curse: The History and Future of Societal Collapse” by Luke Kemp, it seems more likely that with Desolation comes an overlapping Pastoral State and that Consumption is bad for all but a privileged minority.
Check out the newsletter and the five paintings to see what I mean.
P.S. The Pastoral State, below, looks good to me. 🙂

